Should Companies Let Employees Vote on Who Becomes Their Manager?
Learn topic-related expressions and join the speaking club to practice them!
I'm Teacher Michael, a licensed English teacher.
I'm originally from the United States, but I have been working as a full-time TEFL-certified high school English teacher in Thailand since 2013. I have a Bachelor's Degree in International Relations and I am currently studying for my Master's Degree in Liberal Arts.
Topic guide Optional
A quick way to understand the topic and find useful language. Read as much or as little as you like.
1-minute overview
Some companies are asking whether employees should have a say, or even a vote, in who becomes their manager. Supporters argue that staff see daily behaviour that senior leaders miss: who coaches, shares credit, handles conflict fairly and protects the team under pressure. Involving employees may also build trust, improve retention and make a new manager's authority feel more legitimate.
The idea is rare in practice. Even worker-owned firms usually elect board members rather than supervisors, and many organisations prefer a middle path. In a voice model, employees interview candidates and give feedback. In a veto model, leaders promise not to appoint someone the team strongly rejects.
Critics raise several concerns. Popularity is not the same as competence, and a manager must sometimes deliver unwelcome decisions, enforce standards or reward people unequally. Votes can reward charisma, reflect cliques or put candidates in awkward positions. Secrecy may protect honesty but reduce accountability. The key tension is between legitimacy and expertise: who knows best what a team needs?
The idea is rare in practice. Even worker-owned firms usually elect board members rather than supervisors, and many organisations prefer a middle path. In a voice model, employees interview candidates and give feedback. In a veto model, leaders promise not to appoint someone the team strongly rejects.
Critics raise several concerns. Popularity is not the same as competence, and a manager must sometimes deliver unwelcome decisions, enforce standards or reward people unequally. Votes can reward charisma, reflect cliques or put candidates in awkward positions. Secrecy may protect honesty but reduce accountability. The key tension is between legitimacy and expertise: who knows best what a team needs?
Useful vocabulary
Approx. CEFR · Topic relevance
legitimacy
/ləˈdʒɪtəməsi/The accepted right of a person or process to hold authority, because others see it as fair.
A manager chosen with team input may begin with more legitimacy than one simply imposed from above.
veto
/ˈviːtoʊ/The power to block a decision, even if others support it.
Giving employees a veto is different from letting them choose the manager outright.
popularity contest
A choice based on how well-liked someone is, rather than on their ability.
Critics fear that a manager vote would become a popularity contest instead of a search for competence.
accountability
/əˌkaʊntəˈbɪləti/The obligation to explain and take responsibility for one's decisions and results.
If managers depend on team votes, are they more accountable to staff than to executives?
retention
/rɪˈtɛnʃn/A company's ability to keep its employees rather than lose them.
Letting teams shape the choice of manager might improve retention by reducing resentment.
clique
/kliːk/A small, closed group whose members favour one another and exclude others.
A secret ballot may not stop a clique from deciding who is promoted.
Useful expressions
That holds true up to a point, but
Partly agreeing before introducing a limit or counterpoint.
That holds true up to a point, but employees may not see the pressures senior leaders face.
It comes down to whether
Identifying the central issue in a complex debate.
Ultimately, it comes down to whether a manager's job is to represent the team or to direct it.
What are we actually measuring when
Challenging the validity of a method or criterion.
What are we actually measuring when we ask people to vote: skill, likability or familiarity?
By the same token
Adding a parallel point that follows the same logic.
Leaders can misjudge candidates, but by the same token, teams can be swayed by charm.
The trade-off is between
Comparing two competing benefits or costs.
The trade-off is between giving employees real influence and preserving clear managerial responsibility.
Question list
- Ice breaking
- Main topic
- Free talk
| Q1. | You have only 60 seconds before the world is nuked, how are you spending the last minute of your life? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | If you could create a custom holiday just for your friends, what would it be like? |
| Q3. | How do you show kindness on a difficult day? |
| Q4. | What small habit has made a surprising difference in your life? |
| Q5. | What is your favorite type of storytelling: books, movies, or podcasts? |
| Q6. | How do you think the process of cooking and learning about food can foster personal growth and self-discovery? |
| Q7. | What moment helps you feel alive? |
| Q8. | How did you spend your last weekend? |
| Q1. | What qualities would earn your vote for manager? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | How might employees judge candidates differently from senior leaders? |
| Q3. | Should votes for managers be secret? |
| Q4. | Could a popular candidate struggle to lead a team? |
| Q5. | How would voting change the relationship with your manager? |
| Q6. | Who should get a vote when a team hires its manager? |
| Q7. | Should the team vote again after a trial period? |
| Q8. | What part of choosing a manager should employees influence? |
| Q1. | How motivated are you in general? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | Do you believe community service should be required for everyone? Why or why not? |
| Q3. | What helps you avoid comparing yourself to others? |
| Q4. | What role does empathy play in your conversations? |
| Q5. | What do you act like when you're sad or mad? |
| Q6. | What are your thoughts on the impact of social media on politics? |
| Q7. | Have you ever wondered how your life might look if you lived in a different era? |
| Q8. | What are your thoughts on the impact of the gig economy on workers? |
Rules
Please be kind and respectful.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
No flirting! Don't ask for other people's social network, number etc. if he/she refuses to give them.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Give others an equal opportunity to speak.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Avoid Smoking / Drinking while you are talking.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Turning your camera on is mandatory.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Ready to join the conversation?
Book your spot and bring your perspective to the discussion.
