Should Parents Be Allowed to Give Their Children Predictive Genetic Tests?
Learn topic-related expressions and join the speaking club to practice them!
Marhaban everyone! my name is Bilel and I'm from Tunisia . I have a bachelor's degree in English (International Relations). I have worked as a translator, International Business Developer and a director in a teaching center. After COVID, I started my carrier as a part-time English teacher in Tunis, the capital city of Tunisia. I'm an ambitious person, and never give up my dream of working for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Tunisia, and why not be an ambassador someday!?
I'm thrilled to see you all in the Langclub sessions.
Topic guide Optional
A quick way to understand the topic and find useful language. Read as much or as little as you like.
1-minute overview
Predictive genetic tests look for inherited variants associated with a higher chance of developing a condition before symptoms appear. They can be highly valuable when a disease begins in childhood and earlier monitoring, treatment, or prevention can improve outcomes. A result can also clarify a family’s uncertainty and guide medical planning. Yet a result may indicate risk rather than destiny: some variants have incomplete penetrance, and estimates can change as research develops.
The central ethical question is whose interests should lead the decision. Parents normally make health choices for children, but genetic information can shape a young person’s self-image, family relationships, and future choices long after the test. Many professional guidelines therefore support testing when it offers a clear childhood medical benefit, while generally recommending delay for adult-onset conditions with no action needed during childhood. Participants can weigh parental responsibility against the child’s developing autonomy, and consider counselling, privacy protections, secure records, and rules about access by relatives, insurers, schools, and commercial testing companies.
The central ethical question is whose interests should lead the decision. Parents normally make health choices for children, but genetic information can shape a young person’s self-image, family relationships, and future choices long after the test. Many professional guidelines therefore support testing when it offers a clear childhood medical benefit, while generally recommending delay for adult-onset conditions with no action needed during childhood. Participants can weigh parental responsibility against the child’s developing autonomy, and consider counselling, privacy protections, secure records, and rules about access by relatives, insurers, schools, and commercial testing companies.
Useful vocabulary
Approx. CEFR · Topic relevance
predictive genetic test
A test that estimates whether a person may develop a genetic condition in the future.
A predictive genetic test can be useful if it leads to treatment or monitoring during childhood.
penetrance
The extent to which people with a particular genetic variant actually develop the related condition.
Incomplete penetrance means that a positive result does not guarantee that the child will become ill.
clinical utility
The practical medical value of a test result for treatment, prevention, or care decisions.
Before testing a healthy child, doctors should ask whether the result has clear clinical utility.
assent
A child’s informed agreement to a medical decision, even though legal consent comes from a parent or guardian.
An older child may be able to give meaningful assent after the options are explained clearly.
variant of uncertain significance
A genetic change whose connection to disease is not yet known.
A variant of uncertain significance may create anxiety without giving a family a clear medical answer.
genetic counselling
Professional support that helps people understand genetic information and its possible consequences.
Genetic counselling can help parents separate a high risk from a definite diagnosis.
Useful expressions
The decisive issue may be whether...
Use this to identify the principle you think should determine the decision.
The decisive issue may be whether testing changes the child’s medical care now.
We should distinguish between... and...
Use this to prevent two importantly different cases from being treated as identical.
We should distinguish between a childhood-onset disease and an adult-onset risk.
That argument assumes that...
Use this to uncover an unstated belief behind someone’s position.
That argument assumes that knowing more information is always better for a family.
The potential benefit has to be weighed against...
Use this to compare a possible advantage with a possible harm.
The potential benefit has to be weighed against the child’s future right to decide.
A narrow exception might be justified if...
Use this to support a limited policy rather than a complete ban or unrestricted permission.
A narrow exception might be justified if early testing could prevent serious harm.
Question list
- Ice breaking
- Main topic
- Free talk
| Q1. | What is your favorite restaurant? Why? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | Who is your professional role model? |
| Q3. | When have you felt most in tune with the rhythm of life around you? |
| Q4. | What’s a belief or philosophy you’ve developed through personal experience? |
| Q5. | What is your favorite piece of technology, and why? |
| Q6. | Do you like to dance? If so, what type of dance? |
| Q7. | What are some traditions or customs from your family's cultural background that you would like to continue or revive? |
| Q8. | What’s a scent or flavor that brings back a rush of memories for you? |
| Q1. | What kinds of future health risks can genetic tests reveal? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | Why might parents want to test a healthy child? |
| Q3. | Could early knowledge help families prevent disease? |
| Q4. | How could uncertain results affect a child emotionally? |
| Q5. | Should children be able to decide for themselves when they are older? |
| Q6. | Who should be allowed to see a child’s genetic information? |
| Q7. | Could insurers or schools misuse genetic data? |
| Q8. | When, if ever, should predictive testing of children be permitted? |
| Q1. | If you had an unlimited travel budget, where would your first stop be? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | Thinking back on your life, which decisions stand out as most defining? |
| Q3. | Where do you go to feel inspired by art or design? |
| Q4. | What factors contribute to a smooth-running society? |
| Q5. | What would you say if you could give one sentence of encouragement to everyone in the world? |
| Q6. | What do you think your future self will remember about you now? |
| Q7. | Is it more important for governments to invest in defense or education? |
| Q8. | What is your favorite way to show kindness and compassion to others? |
Rules
Please be kind and respectful.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
No flirting! Don't ask for other people's social network, number etc. if he/she refuses to give them.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Give others an equal opportunity to speak.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Avoid Smoking / Drinking while you are talking.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Turning your camera on is mandatory.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Ready to join the conversation?
Book your spot and bring your perspective to the discussion.
