Should Students Be Allowed to Grade Their Teachers?
Learn topic-related expressions and join the speaking club to practice them!
Hello everyone! I'm Geetanjali Tiwari from New Delhi, India. I recently graduated in English and Political Science, and I'm looking forward to beginning my master's journey.I'm an avid reader, a curious learner, and someone who loves meaningful conversations. I believe that language is more than just words, it's a way to connect with people, exchange ideas, and understand different cultures.
That's what I enjoy most about LangClub, and I'm excited to create a welcoming space where we can all learn from one another.
Topic guide Optional
A quick way to understand the topic and find useful language. Read as much or as little as you like.
1-minute overview
Students experience teaching directly every day, so their opinions can reveal whether instructions are clear, the classroom feels respectful, and lessons support learning. Inviting their feedback can also signal that schools take student voice seriously. A short survey, a regular anonymous check-in, or a class discussion may help a teacher notice problems that formal observations miss.
However, asking students to grade teachers raises questions about fairness and purpose. Students may judge a teacher’s personality, a difficult subject, or a disappointing test result rather than the quality of teaching. Research on student evaluations also suggests that ratings can be influenced by bias and by factors outside a teacher’s control. For that reason, feedback may be most useful when it is specific, age-appropriate, confidential, and considered alongside other evidence, such as classroom observations and student learning. The central issue is not simply whether students should evaluate teachers, but how schools can turn their experiences into constructive feedback without reducing teaching to a popularity contest.
However, asking students to grade teachers raises questions about fairness and purpose. Students may judge a teacher’s personality, a difficult subject, or a disappointing test result rather than the quality of teaching. Research on student evaluations also suggests that ratings can be influenced by bias and by factors outside a teacher’s control. For that reason, feedback may be most useful when it is specific, age-appropriate, confidential, and considered alongside other evidence, such as classroom observations and student learning. The central issue is not simply whether students should evaluate teachers, but how schools can turn their experiences into constructive feedback without reducing teaching to a popularity contest.
Useful vocabulary
Approx. CEFR · Topic relevance
student voice
students’ perspectives and influence in decisions that affect their education
Student voice matters most when teachers explain how they used the feedback.
constructive feedback
comments intended to help someone improve, with clear and respectful suggestions
The survey should encourage constructive feedback rather than personal criticism.
anonymity
/ˌænəˈnɪməti/the condition of having one’s identity kept unknown
Anonymity may help students answer honestly, especially when they have concerns.
bias
an unfair preference or judgment that affects an opinion or decision
Schools need to consider possible bias before comparing teachers’ scores.
validity
/vəˈlɪdəti/the degree to which a method measures what it claims to measure
A rating has limited validity if it mainly reflects whether students liked the final exam.
popularity contest
a situation in which people are judged mainly by how well liked they are
Teacher evaluation should not become a popularity contest.
Useful expressions
One distinction worth making is between … and …
Use this to separate two ideas that are often confused.
One distinction worth making is between judging a teacher’s clarity and judging whether a class was easy.
That may be true in principle, but …
Use this to accept part of an argument before adding a limitation.
That may be true in principle, but younger students may need much simpler questions.
The value of this approach depends largely on …
Use this to explain the conditions that make an idea effective.
The value of this approach depends largely on whether teachers receive specific, usable comments.
I would be cautious about treating … as …
Use this to challenge an overly simple conclusion.
I would be cautious about treating one survey score as a measure of teaching quality.
A more balanced solution might be to …
Use this to propose a compromise or combined approach.
A more balanced solution might be to combine student feedback with peer observation and self-reflection.
Sources & further reading
Question list
- Ice breaking
- Main topic
- Free talk
| Q1. | What small step moves you toward growth? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | Have you ever experienced a time when everything seemed to fall into place perfectly? |
| Q3. | Where do you think your creativity is hiding lately? |
| Q4. | What future skill excites you to learn? |
| Q5. | What is your favorite type of vacation: beach, mountain, or city? |
| Q6. | What moment changed your perspective subtly but powerfully? |
| Q7. | What’s a story you’ve heard that you feel compelled to share with others? |
| Q8. | Have you ever met someone famous? Who was it? |
| Q1. | Did you ever have a teacher who listened to students well? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | What could students judge fairly about a teacher? |
| Q3. | Could student grades help teachers improve? |
| Q4. | Might students give low grades after difficult tests? |
| Q5. | Should feedback be private or shared with everyone? |
| Q6. | Would younger students need a simpler way to respond? |
| Q7. | How could schools protect teachers from unfair comments? |
| Q8. | What is one question every teacher should ask students? |
| Q1. | What role do you think sustainable and ethical food practices play in shaping the future of food and culinary culture? |
|---|---|
| Q2. | What is your favorite saying? |
| Q3. | What is one thing you are currently struggling with? |
| Q4. | How would you like to be remembered? |
| Q5. | Why do certain places instantly make you feel at home? |
| Q6. | What are your thoughts on the potential impact of deepfake technology on the credibility of news and media content? |
| Q7. | What risks do you come across in your work/life? |
| Q8. | Do you like crafts? If so what types of craft do you like? |
Rules
Please be kind and respectful.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
No flirting! Don't ask for other people's social network, number etc. if he/she refuses to give them.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Give others an equal opportunity to speak.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Avoid Smoking / Drinking while you are talking.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Turning your camera on is mandatory.
Note: You can be banned for violating any of these rules
Ready to join the conversation?
Book your spot and bring your perspective to the discussion.
